Dram Roll

From single-cask specialists to the world’s biggest Irish whiskey brand, the category is growing again, and the old rules about how it should be drunk are falling away. We spoke to six leading voices about cocktails, curation and confidence, and why whisky now belongs in every venue.

For a long time, whisky did a very good job of keeping people out, and plenty of venues let it: the reserved back bar, the reverence, the assumption that it was a specialist’s category best left to the specialists. What emerges from talking to six people at very different ends of the trade, from one of Glasgow’s best-known whisky pubs to the world’s biggest Irish whiskey brand, is how completely the people selling whisky best have abandoned that thinking. The question for operators is whether their venue has too.

Start with the trajectory. “I see whisky entering a phase of growth, with drinkers coming back as well as new drinkers seeking it out as tastes change and evolve,” says Billy Abbott, Brand Ambassador for The Whisky Exchange, who watches what drinkers actually buy from a rare vantage point. “Mixing interesting whisky is not a crime, and increasingly people are breaking that ancient ‘rule’.”

Nathan Last, On-Trade Channel Director at Pernod Ricard UK, can put numbers on it. Jameson has become a Top 10 spirits brand, growing 6.1 percentage points ahead of the wider imported whiskey market in the on-trade and now accounting for over 20% of imported whiskey value sales. “Irish whiskey remains underrepresented on many back bars compared with categories such as gin and rum, yet consumers are increasingly seeking versatile spirits that work equally well neat, on the rocks and in cocktails,” he says. Growth, in other words, with headroom still in it.

So what held it back? Matt Workman, owner of HopScotch in Liverpool, is blunt about it. “Two elements contribute to the intimidation factor: the drink itself and the culture surrounding it. I believe that much of the whisky industry is designed around exclusivity, and that in itself can be intimidating when you’re faced with dress codes, expensive pours, and formal service.” He always felt out of place in those venues, which is why HopScotch was built as the opposite: relaxed, a bit rough around the edges, alternative music on, more a pub crossed with a whisky bar than a temple.

His answer to the intimidation problem is worth pinning above any back bar. “Come in wearing jeans and a t-shirt, listen to some Alice in Chains, have a dram, tell me it smells like your nan’s trifle, if you think it needs a teaspoon of water then crack on, and most importantly have fun with it. How can a smell or a taste that you’ve pulled from your memory be wrong?”

Iain McPherson, owner of Panda & Sons in Edinburgh, arrives at the same place from the innovation end. “I think sometimes we create a barrier for ourselves by thinking of whisky as particularly tradition-bound. Most spirits are tradition-bound in some way. For us it’s not really about that. It’s about championing the flavours.”

“As much as innovation is a large part of what we do at Panda & Sons, so is promoting Scotland and everything Scottish,” he adds, and the bar’s annual Clan Gathering bottling, a blended malt limited to 100 bottles and released at its Panda Highland Games in aid of the Scottish Wildcat, is proof of it. Panda & Sons is one of the most decorated bars in the country, yet its whisky programme is rooted in the same permission-giving instinct: “I think using more Scottish whisky in cocktails can help break down some of the stigma around how it should be drunk.”

Cocktails are where that stigma goes to die, and every contributor lands on them as the way in. Iain designs for it deliberately. “We believe you need those introductory cocktails for people who come in saying, ‘I don’t like whisky’ or ‘I don’t like Scotch’. Those drinks give people a chance to appreciate the flavours in a more toned-down and approachable way.” Panda & Sons’ Wildling, a long, carbonated sipper, exists for exactly that guest. “That’s often the starting point, getting someone who says they don’t like Scotch to realise they actually enjoy those flavours in a cocktail. From there, they’re much more open to trying different styles and exploring the category.”

Nathan sees the same journey at scale. “Historically, whiskey might have been seen as a neat or rocks serve, but Jameson is increasingly being discovered through longer, more refreshing drinks. Jameson, Ginger & Lime has become a standout serve because it gives guests an easy entry point into the category whilst fitting naturally into contemporary drinking occasions.” For winter menus he points to indulgent, seasonal builds: a Jameson Gingerbread Highball, a Hot Apple Toddy, and an Irish Coffee Martini to catch the Espresso Martini drinker.

Annie Ingram, Prestige Trade Marketing Manager at Disaronno International UK, whose portfolio spans The Busker Irish whiskey and Maryland’s Sagamore Rye, agrees the season is on whiskey’s side. “Whether it’s a rye Old Fashioned, a whiskey sour with depth, or something more adventurous with Irish whiskey at its core, these premium spirits bring the kind of warmth, spice and complexity that cold-weather cocktails are built on.”

The other engine is premiumisation, and here the suppliers are unusually aligned. “Guests are increasingly looking for elevated experiences, but they still want brands they recognise and trust,” says Nathan, whose recommended route is the simple step up: standard Jameson to Black Barrel, or a Black Barrel Old Fashioned as the premium serve. Annie sees it across the whole drinks list. “We’re observing growth of our products in the premium price range across many categories, as people increasingly choose quality over quantity when it comes to what they’re drinking.” The Busker’s positioning as affordable luxury is built for that drinker, able to sit on a cocktail list and stand as a sipping pour at once. Education is part of the pitch too: The Busker’s home, Royal Oak Distillery, produces single malt, grain and pot still styles under one roof, “providing consumers with an educational journey into the category while remaining accessible”.

Billy adds a useful check on all of this: premium only lands when there’s substance behind it. “Story has always been important, but with so many whiskies on the market, it’s become even more so. While drinkers are drawn towards newer and less mainstream styles, smoke, interesting casks, new production techniques, they are also checking for gimmicks. Style choices with good reasons behind them lead to the authentic stories that people want.” His map of where those stories are coming from stretches well past Speyside: Nordic distillers, east Asia, India, Thailand and Korea, and a thriving English whisky scene he calls himself a proponent of, “all a few hours drive away at most”. The category’s centre of gravity is shifting, and menus might as well shift with it.

Which raises the practical question: what actually earns a place on the back bar? Billy’s formula is a core of standard releases with deliberate space for the unfamiliar. “Indie bottlings give alternative looks at more familiar distilleries, but lesser-known distillers give bartenders the opportunity to share new stories, giving guests further insights into what they are drinking.”

At HopScotch, independent bottlings form the lion’s share of the list. Most of the range is single cask, which keeps the offer moving by its nature: once a bottle is gone, it is generally gone for good. Matt’s tip for the enthusiast market is to watch the new wave. “Some of the new distilleries are in my opinion very impressive, such as Ardnamurchan and Dornoch. Both of these have only been distilling for about a decade, but they’re run by people who really know what they’re doing and that shows in the liquid.”

Frank Murphy, proprietor of The Pot Still in Glasgow, manages one of the biggest gantries in the country, and his stocking logic is refreshingly unsentimental: new releases the customer wants to try before buying a bottle, whiskies the team has tasted and rates regardless of the label, oddities that push the envelope, and a fourth category he makes no apology for. “There has to be a benefit to running your own whisky bar, so we have a deep range of distilleries like Benromach and Glen Moray, because I enjoy drinking it.” Pricing is just as brisk. “We have no time for trying to figure out what the customer will accept. The number of bottles that come in and out every week, and the changing prices, means that every dram gets the same percentage applied to the cost price and then up on the bar.” It will horrify the yield-management crowd; it also leaves his team selling whisky rather than second-guessing it.

But Frank is adamant that the range is not the asset. “A groaning gantry deep with drams is lovely to look at, but without a team behind the bar who can find the right whiskies within that, it’s just something to dust.” The Pot Still invests in perpetual learning, tutored tastings, distillery visits and festival tickets shared equally among the team, and the payoff compounds: its alumni now work at Chivas Brothers, Edrington, William Grant’s and half a dozen more, which has itself become a recruitment tool for ambitious bartenders. What he refuses to build is uniformity. “The same customer query should get similar but not identical selections from Sally, Iona, AJ or Lucca, based on their own personal likes and dislikes. That keeps the experience fresh for returning customers also.”

Matt’s version of the same lesson is community. HopScotch’s regulars, its whisky club and its reputation among enthusiasts far beyond Liverpool have carried the bar through a brutal period for hospitality. “Show people your passion and knowledge, people can tell when the passion is genuine. Give people a place where they belong, look after them, and they will rally around you.”

None of which requires a venue to become a whisky bar. On this the panel is emphatic, and specific. “Don’t go full speed ahead into it, leave the big selections and more obscure bottles to the places that really specialise in it,” says Matt. “Maybe start with no more than 10 bottles, but get to know those bottles inside and out so that you and your staff can make solid recommendations.” “There are plenty of knowledgeable, friendly, and passionate people in the industry,” he adds. “Bring one of them in to do a bit of training with you and your staff.”

Iain’s advice is to match the style to the venue rather than defaulting to the famous names: a light single grain for a bar that leans towards white spirits, younger blends that undercut the old-equals-better myth, sherried and sweeter cask finishes for an easier landing. Nathan’s is about visibility: “Make whiskey easy to discover. If guests can’t see it, they won’t order it.” Menu placement, staff confidence and simple stepping stones through the category, he argues, move rate of sale more than anything exotic.

And Frank makes the commercial case in one breath. “You can offer a great range of flavours with even just half a dozen bottles, it doesn’t go off the same way other drinks might, price points go all the way up and down the scale, and there’s never a point where anybody has seen it all.” He adds one benefit nobody else thought to mention: a good dram gives a drinker an out. “If you want to stay part of the group but not the round, few query the person slowly sipping a good dram, while a flat pint quickly gives the game away.”

We half expected a squabble between tradition and innovation somewhere in these interviews. Nobody turned up to have it. The message from these six is remarkably consistent, and quietly radical for a category that once traded on mystique: not one of them argued for gatekeeping. The specialist bars are stripping out the formality, the brands are building entry ramps, and the retailer is telling bartenders to mix the good stuff. Whisky’s fundamentals suit an operator under pressure: it keeps, it sells at every price point on the list, and it rewards knowledge that any team can build six bottles at a time. The venues winning with whisky are simply the ones that stopped asking guests to earn it. A back bar built without that attitude is, to borrow Frank’s phrase, just something to dust.

LATEST EDITION

MENU

Back